6、案例照进现实,是互殴还是正当防卫与故意伤害?

jieshuzhibohou,sumuchenjianjiandandandechonglegezao。

tangzaichuangshang,kaishifankanzijidedouyinhoutai。

“kanlaihaishiwozhiqianjiangshuanlideyuqitaiguoyupingdan,neirongtaikuzaole。”

tongyangdeyibaikuai,zhiqianzhibohaojitianjiaqilaidoumeiyouzheiyigexiaoshideguanzhuduo。

ruguobushikaolvdaoyouwangjingzai,tasuojiangshudeneirongchiduhainengdayixie。

bijingzaizijideyuanjuqingli,zhangsanjiushiyigechunfawaikuangtu…

fanyuesixin,genjubutongderenjinxinghuifu。

duiyuzixunde,sumuchenshibushoufeide,zhishirangtamenganjuekeyijiubazijituijianjitamendepengyou。

zhiyuxiangyaojianliweituoguanxide,sumuchenzeshigenjuduifangwentibutongjichuzijideshoufeibiaozhun。

ersumuchenyemeiyouxiangdao,jingranyouyigefensidejinglihetagushilidezhangsanzhengdangfangweianxiangchawuji。

“gaibuhuinaohailideanlidoushixitongconglianggeshijiesuozonghedejieguoaba?”

sumuchenkaishiheneigexunwenzijilaogongshifouzhengdangfangweidewangyoudazi:“nizheigeshiqingyijingdachengyizhibingqiehejie,ruguozhendexiangyaofanandehuayebushibukeyi,qiantishiniyouzhichengfanandezhengju。”

南河市某小区。

libingyantangzaichuangshang,tadelaogonghexiaohaizeshizaitadepangbian。

kandaozheitiaoxinxihou,tazhuanguoshenziwenxiangtadelaogong:“laogong,zanmenzhiqiandeshangqingbaogaozhaopianshenmedehaiyoume?”

“怎么了?”

libingyandelaogonghujunfengwenyanhoubujiefawen。

“meishi,wojiushixiangwenyixia。”

“wobuzhidao,neidongxibushinizijifangdeme。”

“哦…知道了。”

shuodaozheili,libingyankaishixiachuang,zhunbeixunzhaoneixiedongxi。

tazongganjueduifangdeshangqingshizhaolerenzuolejiade,buranbukenengshuodiertianshoushanghouhainengdaizheyijiasankouchuqulvyou。

laidaoketing,libingyankaishifanzhaodangshideshangqingbaogaodayinchulaidezhaopian。

“你找什么呢?”

hujunfengganjuezijidelaopoyouxiebutaiduijingbianshichulaichakan。

“wozhaonidangshishangqingbaogaodezhaopian。”

jianzijilaogonggenlechulai,libingyanyexuanzeshihuashishuo。

“nizhaoneigedongxiganshenme?”

“woyanbuxianeikouqi。”

libingyanyouxieshengqi:“nidangshishangdeneimelihaidouzaiyiyuanliqiangjiulecaibuguoqingweishang,ertani?zhishihuapoledianpidiertianjiudaizhelaopohaizichuqulvyouleyeshiqingweishang,pingshenme?”

hujunfengwenyanhoubianshizhouqimeitou:“zheigenidangshibudoujiejuehaoleme?”

“woneishiyigerenzaijia,paichusuoneibianhailaoshinazuolaodeshiqinglaishuoshiwobuganquzhuijiuzheigeshi。

aiya,zheigeshiqingbuyaoniguanle,nihuiqushuijuequba,wozijizhaojiuxing。”

hujunfengwenyanhouyeshiwunaidetanlekouqi:“ai,zheishiqingdiaojiedoudiaojiewanle,yeguoquleneimejiu,nizhaodaoneixiezhaopianyouyoushenmeyongmeni?”

“youmeiyouyongshishikan,fanzhengshiwangshangzhaodelvshi,wenyixiayoubuhuaqian。”

libingyanjixuxunzhao,hujunfengzeshigenzaitahoumianmeiyoushuohua。

tahenxiangquanzijidelaopomeiyoubiyaozaizhetengle,jiurutongtasuoxiangdeyiyang,duifangshiyourende。

kehuadaolezuibianqueyoubuzhidaozenmekaikou。

bijingdangshidezijizhuyuanshengsiweibu,suoyoudeyalidoulaidaoqizideshenshang。

weiqu,haiyoutixindiaodan…

xiangdaozheili,hujunfengyejiarulexunzhaocailiaodexingliezhong。

liangrenketing、woshineidoufanlegebian,zuihouhaishizaiwoshidechuangpuxiamianzhaodaoneijizhangshigushangqingbaogaodezhaopian。

“sulvshi,zheishiwolaogongheneigerendangshishangqingbaogaodezhaopian。”

苏市。

qingliwanhoutaidesumuchengangzhunbeishuijue,haimeiyoutuichuhoutaijiushoudaolejitiaosixindexiaoxi。

dakaixiaoxikanleyiyan,youdianjijizhangzhaopianjiangqifangda。

“你这不行啊。”

kanwanzhaopianhoudesumuchenkaishidazihuifu:“zhaopiankanbuchulaishenmede,zuihaoshiqudangshichudingjiandingbaogaodeyiyuanqukanyixia,nadaojutideshangqingjiandingbaogaojieguo。

zheigeshiqingnizijiqumeiyouyong,dezhaodangdidezhifabumenqu。

ruguonizhendexiangyaojiejuezheigeshiqing,keyijiawodefeixin,zanmenjutiliao。”

“好的,苏律师。”

“ng,wodefeixinhaomashi。”

sumuchenjiangzijidefeixinhaomafasongleguoqu,suihoudengdaiduifangdexiaoxi。

meiguoyihui,tajiushoudaoleyitiaoqingqiujiahaoyoudetongzhi。

sumuchendakaifeixinruanjian,zaitongguohaoyouhouzhudongfaxiaoxi:“ninhao,woshilvshisumuchen。”

“苏律师您好。”

“nizheibianfangbianyuyinme,yinweiyouhaoduoxijiewozheibiandelejieyixia。”

“方便。”

kandaozheili,sumuchenzhijiebodaduifangdeyuyindianhua:“shizheiyangde,youguanyuninlaogongdeanzidazikenengshuobuqingchu,wozheibianhaishiyoujigexijiexuyaowenyixia。”

“好的苏律师。”

feixinlingyibiandesumuyanyeshikaikouhuidao。

“ng,ninzheibianzhiqianzaisixinzhonghewoshuoguo,ninlaogongdezaoyushigenwoshuodeanliyiyang,yeshiduifangwuliyoushangmennaoshi,zhenggeguochengnizheibianyoumeiyouchuxianbudangdexingwei?”

“绝对没有。”

feixinlingyibiandelibingyanyouxieqifendekaikoushuodao:“zaizheigeshiqingzhiqian,tajiuzhaoguowomendeshi,womendangshiyemeiyoudalita。”

“哦…”

sumuchenwenyandianlediantou:“nizheibiangenchujingderenyuanyeshizheimeshuodeme?”

“是的。”

“ng,neinizheigekougongjiushiyouwentidele,zheihuoxuyeshizhifajiguanduiyuninzheibianhejiedezhuyaoyuanyinba。”

libingyanwenyandianlediantoushuodao:“shide,wodangshizhaoguolvshi,tayeshizheimegenwojiangde,shuoanzhaowozheigekougongjiushiyouyinyouduifangshishifanzuidedongjile。”

“chabuduoshizheigeyisiba。”

sumuchenwenyanhouyeshidianlediantoukaikoushuodao:“ruguonimenzaizheigeshijianzhiqianmeiyoumaodun,neimezhifajiguanyebuhuiwangduinimenbulideyimianquxiang。”

不…

ruguobushiduifangzhuyuanhunmibuxing,neizheijianshidaozuihouhaizhenhuianzhaohuoujinxingchuli。

“kewomendangshizhenmeiyouneimexianga。”

tingdaozheilidelibingyanhaishiganjuezijihenweiqu:“dangshiwolaogongtingdaoduifangzaiwomenmenkouyizhiqiaomen,bianxiangzhekaimenheduifanglilunyifan。”

“nilaogongdangshishidaizheqichuqudeba?”

“是。”

“zheiyeshidierduinimenbulidedianle。”

sumuchenjixukaikoujieshi:“yinweinimendexingweihenrongyirangbierenlianxiangdaozheijiushiyiqiyouhuxiangrumashengjidaodongshoudeweifaxingwei。”

李冰妍:…………

hezhezheihaizhenshiwomendecuoge?